Repairing vs. Replacing Furniture: Which Option is Best for You?

When your furniture faces wear and tear, whether it’s from your dog shaking off rain-soaked fur, kids running with muddy shoes or the occasional wine spill, deciding between repair or replacement can be challenging. Furniture, often seen as an investment, carries not only functional but also sentimental value. But how do you determine when to repair and when to replace?

This article will break down key considerations and guide you in choosing the best option based on your needs.

Key Takeaways

• Understand the sentimental and practical value of your furniture before making a decision. 
• The cost of repair or replacement varies based on furniture type and the severity of the damage.
• Cosmetic versus structural damage plays a big role in cost determination. Cosmetic repairs are normally more expensive than structural repairs since they require more work and it isn’t necessary.
• La-Z-Boy offers a comprehensive Furniture Protection Plan that can help protect your investment for five years.

 In This Article...

Factors to Consider

When determining whether to repair or replace furniture, there are several important factors to weigh.

1. Sentimental Value

Before diving into logistics or finances, ask yourself if the piece holds sentimental value. A family heirloom, the couch from your first home, or a unique antique might be irreplaceable, regardless of cost. If a furniture piece carries sentimental value, opting for repair may be a simple decision. 

However, if the piece is strictly functional, additional factors must be considered, such as cost-effectiveness and practicality.

2. Type of Furniture

Furniture types vary widely, and so do their repair costs. For instance, repairing a small bedside table will likely cost much less than reupholstering a large sectional sofa. 

The nature of the furniture (whether stationary or mobile) also impacts the repair costs. Large upholstered items like sofas, sectionals, or recliners tend to incur higher repair costs, especially when it comes to reupholstery or structural damage. For items like sofas, knowing how much a sofa costs can provide context for comparing repair vs. replacement costs.

3. Extent of Damage

Assess the type of damage—cosmetic or structural. Cosmetic issues such as minor scratches, stains, or small tears are generally cheaper to repair. 

However, structural damage like broken frames, split wood, or faulty springs often requires more expertise and costlier repairs. In such cases, replacing the furniture may be a more viable option, particularly if the overall integrity is compromised.

4. DIY or Professional Repair?

You might consider fixing the issue yourself, especially for minor repairs, which can save money. DIY projects, do require time, effort, and the right tools. 

On the other hand, hiring a professional contractor or technician ensures high-quality results, particularly for more complicated repairs, and reduces the risk of injury. Professional repairs come at a higher cost but often guarantee longevity.

Repair vs Replace: Cost Analysis

Here’s a breakdown of the costs associated with repairing versus replacing different types of furniture.

Sofas & Upholstered Furniture Repair Costs in Ontario:

Conclusion: If your sofa has extensive wear, such as frayed fabric or a broken frame, replacing it might be more economical than reupholstering, especially for larger sectionals. However, minor fabric tears could justify opting for a repair.

Dining Tables & Chairs Repair Costs in Ontario:

Conclusion: Minor scratches and dents can be easily repaired at home. However, for refinishing, it may be more cost-effective to replace the table entirely if the cost approaches or exceeds that of a new set.

Cabinets Repair Costs In Ontario:

Conclusion: Cabinet repair is usually more cost-effective than replacement unless you consider a full kitchen renovation.

How to Make Your Furniture Last Longer

To maximize the life of your furniture, follow these care tips:

• Regular Maintenance: Clean and condition your furniture regularly, especially if it's made of leather or wood.
• Use Protective Covers: Shield furniture from pet scratches or spills with easy-to-clean, removable covers.
• Professional Cleaning: Invest in professional cleaning services for upholstery to maintain its appearance and extend its lifespan.
• High-Performance Fabrics: Consider La-Z-Boy’s iClean fabrics, which offer protection against spills and stains, reducing the likelihood of needing repairs or replacements.

La-Z-Boy Furniture Protection Plan

What's Next?

Deciding whether to repair or replace your furniture depends on various factors, including sentimental value, type of damage, and cost. 

If you’ve exhausted your options for repair or are ready for something new, visit a La-Z-Boy showroom in Ottawa or Kingston to explore options that suit your style and budget. 

Our team is ready to help you find the perfect replacement or offer expert advice on repairs. Additionally, don't miss the opportunity to utilize our interior designers, who can assist you in creating a design project that harmonizes seamlessly with your home.

Related Links:

Is La-Z-Boy Warranty Worth it?

Furniture Care Tips

How to Get Rid of Old Furniture